HomeThe ProblemROICase StudiesAboutResourcesPricingContact Start Hiring →
Personal injury intake playbook

Personal Injury Lead Follow-Up: The Speed-to-Lead Cadence

An injured person who fills in a form is often calling other firms the same hour. Here is the eight-touch follow-up cadence an intake specialist runs, scripts for every touch, the rules to stay inside and the numbers that show what works.

  • 8-touch cadence
  • Calls, texts and emails
  • English and Spanish
Hire a PI intake specialist →See the cadence

Follow-up in one box

  • 5 minutes to the first callback
  • Text if no answer, with consent
  • Evening call the same day
  • Days 2, 4, 7: calls at new times
  • Close with a clear message

How should a personal injury firm follow up with new leads?

Answer calls live and call every web form or missed call back within five minutes. If there is no answer, send a text (to people who contacted the firm and gave consent), call again within the hour with an email, call once that evening, then on days 2, 4 and 7 at different times, and close with a clear message. Every attempt is logged in the case-management system, and every successful call ends with a booked consultation.

5 minto the first callback
8touches before closing a lead
1evening call the same day
100%of attempts logged
48%of law firms were unreachable by phone in Clio's secret-shopper study
40%picked up when a prospective client called
33%answered an emailed inquiry

Source: Clio Legal Trends secret-shopper findings, linked under Sources.

The eight-touch cadence

  1. 1
    Minute 0Answer live or call back in 5 minutes

    Calls answered on the first rings; web forms and missed calls called back within five minutes, while the person is still near the phone.

  2. 2
    Minute 6Text if no answer

    A short text with the firm's name, why you're reaching out and a direct number, only to someone who contacted the firm.

  3. 3
    Hour 1Second call and email

    A second call from the same number, then an email with a booking link and what to have ready.

  4. 4
    Same eveningEvening call

    Injured people are at work, in treatment or with family by day. One call between 5 and 8 pm their time.

  5. 5
    Day 2Morning call and text

    A different time of day than the first attempts.

  6. 6
    Day 4Call plus a useful message

    What to keep: photos, medical bills, the claim number. Still a booked consult as the ask.

  7. 7
    Day 7Last call and a closing message

    "We'll close your inquiry for now; reply any time and we'll pick it up."

  8. 8
    Day 30Check-in, if your rules allow

    One message for leads closed as no-contact, if the person agreed to hear from you.

Leads called back in minutes, every time. Intake specialists shortlisted in 5–8 days.Hire a PI intake specialist →

The first week, touch by touch

Touches in the first week of the cadence above. The bars show the order of attempts, not response rates; your own call logs show which touch your leads answer.
See this as a table
WhenTouch
Minute 0–51st attempt
Minute 62nd touch
Hour 13rd–4th touch
Same evening5th touch
Days 2–76th–9th touch

Lead sources and the first move for each

Every lead gets its source logged, so the firm can see which sources become signed cases.
See this as a table
SourceFirst move
Phone callsLive answer, 5-minute callback
Web forms and chat5-minute call, text, email
Paid lead vendorsImmediate call, confirm consent, log vendor
ReferralsSame-day call, thank the referrer

Scripts for every touch

First callback (web form)

Specialist: "Hi, is this Maria? This is Daniela from Reyes & Clark. You sent us a message a few minutes ago about your accident on I-95. I'm sorry you're dealing with this. Is now a good time for a few questions so an attorney can review it?"

Name, firm, the reason, empathy, then permission.

Voicemail

Specialist: "Hi Maria, it's Daniela from Reyes & Clark returning your message about your accident. You can reach me directly at 555-0142 until 8 tonight. I'll also send you a text."

Under 20 seconds, a direct number and the next touch named.

Text

Text: "Hi Maria, Daniela from Reyes & Clark here about your accident message. When is a good time for a quick call? You can also book with an attorney here: [link]. Reply STOP to opt out."

Only to people who contacted the firm and gave a number, with an opt-out.

"I already talked to another firm"

Caller: "Another lawyer already called me."
Specialist: "Thanks for telling me. Have you signed anything with them? … If not, you're welcome to speak with Attorney Clark too before you decide. Would tomorrow at 10 work?"

Respectful, no pressure, and never comment on the other firm.

Spanish-speaking lead

Especialista: "Hola, ¿hablo con María? Le habla Daniela de Reyes & Clark. Nos escribió hace unos minutos sobre su accidente. Siento mucho lo que está pasando. ¿Tiene unos minutos para unas preguntas, para que un abogado revise su caso?"

Same cadence and script in the caller's language; notes in English.

Closing message (day 7)

Email: "Hi Maria, we've tried to reach you a few times about your accident and don't want to bother you. We'll close your inquiry for now. If you'd like to talk to an attorney, reply here or call 555-0142 and we'll pick it up right away."

A clear close often gets the reply the other touches didn't.

Rules to stay inside

  • Follow up only with people who contacted the firm or asked to be contacted; never cold-contact accident victims
  • Check your state bar's rules on solicitation and advertising before you write the cadence
  • Get consent before texting and include an opt-out; check the TCPA and state texting rules with your counsel
  • Use the firm's approved wording for fees ("no fee unless we win" only if your state and your agreement allow it)
  • Never promise an outcome or a settlement amount
  • Log every attempt in the case-management system so two people never call the same lead

General information, not legal advice. Rules on solicitation, advertising and texting differ by state; check them with your counsel.

Who decides what

Your intake specialistYou or your team
TaskOwnerRule
First callback and cadenceIntake specialistEvery touch logged in the system
Intake form and qualifying answersIntake specialistThe firm's PI form, every field
Medical and liability questionsAttorneySpecialist records, never advises
Accepting or declining the caseAttorneyAfter the consultation
Closing a lead as no-contactIntake specialistAfter the last touch in the cadence
Cadence and wording changesAttorney or intake managerReviewed with call recordings

Shifts: leads answered after 5 pm

Swipe sideways to see the full day →

Lead coverageCoverage strip: a Colombia intake specialist on the US day and a Philippines specialist covering US evenings and late nights.00:0003:0006:0009:0012:0015:0018:0021:00US Eastern PI firmColombia specialistPhilippines specialistShaded = 09:00–17:00 US Eastern (standard time). Bars = each shift in US Eastern time.
Injury leads keep coming after 5 pm. A Colombia specialist covers the business day in English and Spanish; a Philippines specialist covers 3 pm to midnight US Eastern. US standard time shown.
See this as a table
SpecialistLocal hoursUS Eastern hours
Colombia08:00–17:0008:00–17:00
Philippines04:00–13:0015:00–00:00

Recruiting: Colombia and Mexico for bilingual daytime intake, the Philippines for evenings.

Leads answered after 5 pm. Evening and bilingual specialists.Hire a PI intake specialist →

What to measure

01Speed to first attemptMinutes from lead to first call, median
02Contact rateLeads reached live, divided by all leads
03Contact by touchWhich attempt reached the person: first, second, evening
04Consults bookedQualified leads with a consultation booked
05Signed cases by sourceSigned engagement letters per lead source

Start with speed to first attempt and contact rate. Signed cases by source tells you where to spend next.

Want speed to lead on one screen? Meet finalists with recorded calls.Hire a PI intake specialist →

Hire a PI intake specialist who calls back in minutes

Candidates take a recorded mock call with an injured, stressed caller before you meet them. Shortlist in 5–8 days; 6-month replacement guarantee.

Book a free hiring call →

Questions about personal injury lead follow-up

How fast should a personal injury firm follow up with a new lead?

Within minutes. Answer calls live and call web forms back within five minutes, while the person is still near the phone. Clio's secret-shopper research found 48% of law firms unreachable by phone, so speed alone sets a firm apart.

How many times should intake contact a PI lead?

A common cadence is eight touches over about a week: a call within five minutes, a text, a second call and email in the first hour, an evening call, then calls on days 2, 4 and 7 with a closing message. Track which touch reaches your leads and adjust.

Is it legal to text personal injury leads?

Text people who contacted your firm and gave consent, with an opt-out in every message. Rules on texting consent (including the TCPA) and on lawyer solicitation vary; check them with your counsel and your state bar. This is general information, not legal advice.

What should an intake specialist say if the lead already called another firm?

Ask whether they have signed anything. If not, offer a consultation with your attorney so they can compare, without commenting on the other firm or pressuring them.

Who should run PI lead follow-up?

A dedicated intake specialist who owns the cadence, works evenings when leads come in and logs every attempt. Talentige recruits bilingual specialists in Colombia and Mexico and evening coverage in the Philippines. See hire a legal intake specialist.

How do I hire a PI intake specialist?

Test them on a recorded mock call with an injured, stressed caller. Talentige shows a shortlist in 5–8 days, hire in 1–2 weeks and a 6-month replacement guarantee. Compare options in the best legal intake services.

Sources

  1. Clio, "Are law firms failing at marketing and client engagement?" (Legal Trends secret-shopper findings: 52% of firms reached by phone, 40% picked up, 48% unreachable; 33% answered email): https://www.clio.com/guides/client-intake-legal-trends/. Checked 19 Nov 2026.
  2. American Bar Association, Model Rule 5.3: Responsibilities Regarding Nonlawyer Assistance: https://www.americanbar.org/groups/professional_responsibility/publications/model_rules_of_professional_conduct/rule_5_3_responsibilities_regarding_nonlawyer_assistant/. Checked 19 Nov 2026.
  3. American Bar Association, Formal Opinion 08-451, Lawyer's Obligations When Outsourcing Legal and Nonlegal Support Services: https://www.americanbar.org/products/ecd/chapter/220013/. Checked 19 Nov 2026.

Page updated . Spot a mistake? Email contact@talentige.com and we will fix it.

Get a free shortlist for this role

Not ready to book a call? Tell us the role and we will send you pre-screened candidate profiles by email. You pay nothing until you hire.

  1. 1Tell us the role and your hours
  2. 2Get your shortlist in 5–8 days
  3. 3Interview and hire in 1–2 weeks
From $1,200/month ($6.90/hour)6-month replacement guarantee12,850+ hires since 2015

We reply by email. Prefer to talk? Book a free hiring call.